I have lived in a city where public transport was as ubiquitous and as thoughtless as it gets. People owned cars in that city only so they could travel beyond the umbrella of the transport. The bus, the metro, the tram, just part of daily life. Millions of people moved every day at minimal cost.
I now live in a region with transport that aspires to that goal but has absolutely fallen short. Understandably; this is California. The car rules. But I do take the bus to work sometimes, and there are trains to take me farther if I ever had a reason to. The tech companies also have private mass transit.
Apparently BART and CalTrain have never recovered from COVID, and are going to have to seriously cut services without a bailout. I am about to vote on that.
Top line: people should not be required to have a car to have a job. Beyond that, it is cheaper for everyone if there is healthy public transit. Gas prices and time wasted in traffic are the most measurable costs of loss of public transport, but there is also air quality and insurance costs and road repairs (somehow the cost of adding lanes to freeways doesn’t come up in these conversations). Public Transport saves everyone money. Public transport could be completely free, no cost to riders at all, and it would still save everyone money.
Importantly, the tech companies have their own transport systems because current services are inadequate, but many, many well-compensated people ride from towns fifty miles distant, rather than drive. They moved there precisely because there was a BART station. Transit is not only for the poor; it benefits all.
So RTM is almost a no-brainer, except for one thing: it’s funded with a sales tax, the most regressive tax we have. The aforementioned poor will be paying a larger share of their income to keep things alive, subsidizing the wealthier riders. That’s backwards!
Were I King of the Bay Area, I would be adding trains and busses to existing routes and not adding any more lane-miles to the freeways. Those are expensive! I’d focus transit improvements on places where traffic jams occur every day. There are plenty to choose from. And I’d make transit completely free, always, to everyone.
How to pay for it? The obvious target is gasoline, but you can’t just charge every vehicle. The gasoline tax would ideally apply only to commuters who chose to drive, rather than use transport. But when framed that way, the answer is pretty simple: vehicles certified as work trucks for a particular purpose are exempted from the tax at the pump*. José’s landscaping truck does not pay the tax, Karen’s death mobile she parks in two spaces at work pays.
Leave the roads for the people who actually need the roads to move goods and get their tools to a jobsite. Public transport is for the rest of us.
* \* Bureaucratic Nightmare!” people shout. This is the mantra of the corrupt, who don’t want oversight. Work-truck certification would be simple, gas pumps already read cards, and there would be fraud but it would be small next to the net benefit.












